Steve, I have a little more info, and can correct a little of yours. Caroline and John (NOT Jonathan) married in the Parish Church of Thornhill on October 7th 1839. John's age wasn't known but Caroline was 17. Their fathers were James (NOT Edward) Gooder and John Asquith. (I have a copy of the certificate). I found a record for a John, son of James on the Mormon site baptised 23rd October 1814, Thornhill. I also found an entry for a James Gooder marrying a Hannah Lee 17th Sept 1810, which is about the right time, and Hannah is a common family name. I also found an entry for Caroline baptised 26th July 1823 daughter of John and Rachel and an entry for John Asquith marrying Rachel Oldroyd on Christmas Day 1815 at Flockton, nr Thornhill.
I didn't know about Charlotte, Joseph or Wallace but I'm gg grandson of Hannah. She married Francis Auty 12th January 1862 in Dewsbury but by 1875 the had moved to Blackpool, Lancs via Scotland and Batly. All the info I have can be seen at my web site -www.theoultons.com - which I'm trying to get on to some search engines but failing miserably!