Forgot to mention that my hubby is descended from Elihue Baldwin's half-sister, Eliza Lydia House, who later married Wellington Warrenburg. "Lydie" is my hubby's g-g-grandmother. I have a picture of her, taken about 1929, two years or so before she died.
I know that Perry Barngrover moved to Indy after 1899. But, again, I don't know what happened to Elihue and Mary's two sons, and if you have any info on them, I'd love to have it.
As for Asa Baldwin's background, I know nothing. I believe he came to Indiana with brothers and perhaps his father. He died intestate, but his estate is one of the earliest in Shelby Co., IN.
I do have Mary Yoke Baldwin Leach House's--although documentation is not solid except for her father.