Unfortunately I have come up dryon anything on her side so far. I did find a record of marriage in Marengo County of J.A. Bealty rather than Baty marrying Benjamin Franklin Whitcomb in 1872, so now the water is even more muddy. All of us on on Maternal side have always thought it was Baty, but then we are just continuing to dig. I'm sorry I can't help confirm at all if it is the same family!