I found BEATTY's & AVERY's living in Ulster CTY NY mostly around Krumville, Olive, Marbletown.There is a Charles BEATTYb. 1824 d Jan 30 1907 m Anna PALEN b 1830 d. Nov 7 1911 had Frances Ophelia BEATTY who marriedBenjamin MERRIHEW
I also found a Charles BEATTY who died much earlier but can not link him to the above Charles.
Also the AVERY line is linked to the BEATTY/MERRIHEW/OAKLEY/KRUM lines & you should find a lot of info in Ulster CTY NY. I have a Rebecca AVERY who m.Isaiah OAKLEY before 1809 in Marbletown Ulster CTY NY I hope we can share info.