Oh yeah one more thought. If Susie Bigby claims to be a decendant of Chief Broom through her mother than she has to be claiming through either Mary or Elizabeth because Catherine Foreman's mother was Susie Bark or Gourd who was not a decendant of Chief Broom. I do not know why that did not dawn on me sooner. This genealogy is tricky stuff. Thanks again! Love, your Cherokee blood. Ronnie Sellers.