Try going to rootsweb.com world connect project: Family of Rev. Jeremiah Horn. The person that posted this states that James Bigby and Catherine Foreman Bigby did have a daughter named Susie Bigby b. abt. 1820. She was Thomas Wilson Bigby's sister. Also, Thomas Wilson Bigby and Margaret Catherine Adair Bigby had a daughter, Susannah Bigby b. abt.1846. I don't know who the husbands of either of these Susie's were. But maybe the dates will help in your search.