Ann, I was looking at Meigs County Marriages today, I have the Wes Cochran book, and I found a Sarah Chevalier m. Charles Bigley 27 April 1851 in Meigs County.
When I looked at the 1840 Ohio Meigs census for my ancestor, John Chevalier b. 1800, the census said 3 male children and 5 female children.Yet, when I looked at the 1850 census there were 3 sons and 3 daughters (and one baby born that year).I think that's when John's first wife, Jane Reese Chevalier died.Next door is Charles Bigley and Sarah Bigley.I think Sarah Bigley is Sarah Chevalier, one of John's daughter.Where did you get the idea that her name was Shivley?Could it have been Chevalier?I found Charles (37) Sarah (29) John (9) Marietta (7) David (4) Charles 3 and Simeon (2) on the 1860 Meigs, Olive Twp. census.I'll check the Illinois census as you suggested, but when was Andrew born?I feel foolish that I didn't catch this before. Zoe