Hi, Chris. Sorry, I don't have any info on your Bonesteels - except that we're probably related, since my great-grandmother is Jennifer Bonesteel who lived in Ulster County (Arkville). She was married to William Jones, b. 5/14/1874, d. 1/1963. She was the daughter of Isaac Bonesteel and Alice Dunham. That's all I know so far. Maybe someone will see this and tie up all the names somehow. Good hunting!