Lydia BOUTELL is something of a mystery to me.I have the following marriages in my data base:
Lydia BOUTELL m. Reading, MA 8 Mar 1774 James BRYANT
Lydia BOUTELL m. Amherst, NH 27 Apr 1775 Simeon SMALL
The second marriage doesn't appear in the standard record sources - I found it in an old manuscript, "Marriages Performed by Rev. Daniel Wilkins, Amherst, New Hampshire, 1774-1778," in the New Hampshire Historical Society Library.
As you can see, there is a BOUTELL-SMALL connection here, but the marriage record names Simeon whereas you have Jonathan.Any ideas on this?Do you have any records, such as gravestones, that might suggest dates here?
An additional problem is that I know of only one Lydia BOUTELL who is a likely candidate for either of these marriages, and no leads so far as to which one fits.