Thanks. I had been looking at the 1880 census for the past few days, but it listed Catherine age 29 as daughter instead of daughter in law, but it probably is in error. I know I have the right family though. Jerry (Jeremiah) married Sina Higgins. Her mother was Ella Ostrander. Elmer married Effie Jane Ostrander, and Carrie b. 1876 married Harvey Ostrander so the Bush's must have lived close by. Thanks again.