Would it be possible that George had a brother named Frederick? I have both a George and Frederick Cailey in Highland Co. OH in the early 1800's.
My ancestor is a Ferderick Cailey that married a Mary Roadheaffer in Rockingham VA, then moved almost immeadeately to Highland Co. OH.
I have in front of me the biographical sketch of Andrew S. Cailey of East Danville OH. I also have a sketch of George A. G. Sonner, son of Jacob and Christina (Ambrose) who married Clarissa Cailey, a daughter of Frederick Cailey, from Well Co. Indiana.
As I said in another post, my information is from the work of someone else, one of my Byrd relation, and I am following along to prove it.