I did find William Riley Caplinger (b. abt 1842, Highland Co., OH - d. 1906), married (Aug 29, 1867) to Abigail Ross (b. abt 1844, Highland Co., OH - d. May 31, 1883 Ross Co., OH), but that was all I had.
This helps tremendously.
I'm still hot on the trail of my John Cary Caplinger (b. 1855). Jacob and Tene might be his parents...he would have been at the end of that list. ;-)