Hi Cynthea. Thank you for the response. I have since found some additional information from an 80 year old relative. I have written back to her for more. Seems as if Arminda's last name was spelled Carnagey and at some point changed to Carnegie. Possibly this had also been the original spelling. Her parents were Henry G. Carnagey and Sarah Elizabeth Frasier. Her siblings included: Martha, Sarah Ann, William Henry, Evin, Amanda, Amy Ann, Luella, Margaret Ann, Mary Elizabeth and Alexander. I have sent for info on Grandparents as she said Arminda had listed the information above in a family Bible. I had originally asked only for parents and siblings, but will see if she has more. She also said she has descendants, which I believe I forgot to ask her about in the letter that I just sent out. That will be next. I may have asked if any were doing research.