Hi Henrietta, We could still be talking about the same James Carroll.
Here is some information but I cannot remember where I obtained it. William Carroll born 1755 died 1824. Had son James Carroll 1789-1873 m. 1816 to Lucy Gregory Had son John Carroll 1795-1873 m. 1st. 1820 Melinda Haskins Had daughter Phoebe Carroll 1801-1872 m. 1823 Peter Gregory Had son Richard Carroll 1798-1875 m. Dorcas Haskins Had daughter Elizabeth Carroll 1782-1854 William Carroll married Phoebe Wortman 1785 and married Joanna Wakefield. Does this John Carroll fit. Might be a lead to follow-up on. Larry