This is a response to a very old message.I hope you are still using the forum.
We have a Catherine Carroll b abt 1836 in Delaware Co.,NY that we believe married Jacob Weaver and lived in Tioga Co. and/or Lycoming Co. PA.
We are pursuing and testing the hypothesis that Catherine was the daughter of Samuel Carroll and Elizabeth REYNOLDS Carroll and sister of Hannah CARROLL Howard and John W. Carroll and other kids (James, Anorah?).
My grandfather was so convinced that we are descended from Charles Carroll of Carrollton that he named my father after him (Charles Carroll Howard)
In looking at descendancy charts from C. C. of Carrollton Ihave been unable to find the slightest morsel of evidence to support my grandfather's claim but have not totally ruled it out.
I would be happy to share what I have about the Carrolls.