Carolyn, My research leads me to believe that my grt grt grandfather William Aulsey Carroll's father was Clemuel Clement Carroll, brother of Charles Carroll of your line(John Stanton's father). It looks like Charles & Clemuel Clements parents were Benjamin CARROLL and Nancy PEELER I haven't done much research down the other Carroll families so I don't have any more info on the TERRY's nor Mahalia O'CARROLL. If I do come across anything I will surely pass it on to you. Do you have any pictures passed down on the CARROLL's? I am extremely interested in any original documents or photos.
If you want to share more info on our two Carroll families please email me: firstname.lastname@example.org