I have Carroll ancestors from Aghamore North and South, very near to yours. They would have gone to the same church. I have some good information on mine from the church records at Abbydourney and from civil records. The farthest back I go is the 1840s. I will try to e-mail you a powerpoint file from my officetomorrow (file is too large for my dial up)that summarizes all I know (and whatIdon't know) about about them.
My task at the moment is to try to figure out exactly when the North Kerry Carrolls arrived in Kerry from the old Ely O'Carroll territory in the Midlands