Let me look at what I have will get back later, I would assume it is probably the same family. There is a Carroll DNA test going on... I think what they have said is it goes back to Demse Carroll Sr.If you will look on the foard you will see a post about the DNA... I have never known a Carroll family member I descend through Demse Carroll/Dempsey James in the Bible, I have been told ...one of the daughters Athaliza Carroll Pinkston Jarrett, I descend through Athaliza Carroll and husband Shadrack Pinkston... of we thinkMaryland ...Virginia and Georgia. We find him in Virginia where he married AthalizaSanford, b. 1741-46,d. April 8 -28 1777 Fauquier County, m. (bond) 13 February 1771 Fauquier County, Elizabeth (Betty) Bartlett, daughter of Thomas and Anne, d. after 1820 Harrison County. She m. (2) Thomas Asbury . Three children.
Fauquier Co, VA Deeds (bk5,p1-2); 6 Mar 1771: Judson COOLEDGE and Mary, his wife, of Prov. of Maryland to Thomas BARTLETT ... a tract of land in the County of Fauquier in the Colony of Virginia, granted by the Lord Proprietor of the Great Neck in Virginia to John CLARK of Salem in New England and by said John CLARK sold and conveyed to James CAMPBELL and by the said James CAMPBELL and Judith, his wife, sold and conveyed to said Judson COOLIDGE ... one year lease ... 1748 acres in Fauquier Co. for 5 shillings; wit: Sanford CARROLL, Reuben STROTHER, William YATES. Recorded 27 Apr 1772.
Sanford Carroll's Will
Fauquier Co, VA Wills (bk1,p310); 8 Apr 1777; Will of Sanford CARROLL of Parish of Leeds: wife Elizabeth 150 acres of land jointly with Silvester WELCH, the plantation I now live on ... children Anna and Demsey Porter CARRELL and Sally CARRELL; Sig: Sanford CARRELL. Ex: wife and Capt. John OBANON; Wit: Thomas BARTLETT, Silvester WELCH, James BARTLETT. Proved 28 Jul 1777 by oaths of Thomas and James BARTLETT. [James BARTLETT?: brother to Thomas?, or James BARKELY?; James BARTLETT, son of Thomas BARTLETT, b 1771 and could witness...] Fauquier Co, VA Wills (WB1, p318) Estate of Sanford CARRELL dec'd; Appraised by John FISHBACK, Ephriam HUBBARD and Samuel GROGSBY
Fauquier Co, VA Wills (WB2, p185) 27 Jan 1791 Adm’R Acc’ and Division of Sanford CARROLL: Adm: Col. John O’BANNON; Due estate by O’BANNON from Dec 1787, L17.6.10,3 three legatees: David PRUNTY, who married Anna CARROL, L5.15.7-1/2, also Negroes Harry & Alley with L8.6.8 which he obtained by Lott (other legatees not named). Div by: Henry PEYTON, Law ASHTON, Wm. METCALF. Returned: 28 Feb 1791. [other 2 ch: Dempsey Porter, Sarah].