Are you the Stephen who has the Catlin genealogy on FamilyTreeMaker? I've referred several Catlin researchers to the site over the years. I checked the Mitchells and Abraham Catlins in Louise Roloson's book but with no luck. Most of the Mitchells were children of Catlin women who married Mitchells. Not that cousins don't marry cousins--however none were identified as having married an Abraham Catlin. I also checked for Abraham's other wives (from Catlin website) trying to find him but with no luck--their surnames are not in the index.