Lynn- There are about ten George W. Chaffee's listed in "THE CHAFFEE GENEALOGY" by William H. Chaffee, but none shown married to an Ann Smith. There are about 100 George Chaffee's listed. What is the time frame? Any birth, marriage, death dates for any of the family you listed? Where did they marry, live, and die? The index of the book includes town names; a town name might lead to the right branch of the Chaffee family. Most of the information in the book was gathered about 1880-1900; anything later would not be in it.