Don, The only thing I have discovered is that Polly's first husband's surname was Justine or Justines.
Here are her family details, including siblings and ancestors back to Thomas the immigrant: ALPHA(5) CHAFFEE (ATHERTON4, DAVID3, NATHANIEL2, THOMAS1) was born in WESTMINISTER, VT. ALPHA died BLACK LAKE, ST. LAWERENCE, NY.
He married MARY ABBY. MARY was born 1768. MARY was the daughter of JOHN ABBY. MARY died 1872 ST. CLAIR, MICH., at 104 years of age.
ALPHA CHAFFEE and MARY ABBY had the following children: i. RACHEL6 CHAFFEE. She married JOHN BALDWIN. ii. SOPHIA CHAFFEE. SOPHIA died 1850 ST. CLAIR. She married HEZEKIAK HASKELL. iii. POLLY CHAFFEE. POLLY died 1870. She married twice. She married MR JUSTINES. She married WILLIAM BOWMAN. iv. LONSON CHAFFEE. v. MATILDA CHAFFEE. vi. PHOEBE CHAFFEE. vii. JOHN CHAFFEE. JOHN died HERKIMER, NY. He married twice. He married CAROLINE SHAW WASHINGTOM, MICH.. He married MARY CLARK. viii. ALPHA CHAFFEE (JR) was born 8/2/1800. He married EFFIE KELCH.