It seems we have a connection thru Ophelia L. Martin Chase. I'm actually trying to go back a few generations. Do you have much information going back?
I have Ophelia's parents as Mary Ann Smallin and Seneca "Perly" Page Martin. I do not have the parents Mary or Seneca, but I am trying to find them.
I suspect Mary Ann Smallin is related to John D. Smallin (b. abt 1798 and lived in Otsego county) and Mehabitable Smallin (wife - b. abt 1796).... The reason I think they're related to Mary Ann is because Mary Ann and Seneca named one of their daughters Mehitable. So perhaps Mehitable is Mary Ann's mother or grandmother?
I should mention this is not my direct family - I am helping my husband's cousin's wife with her genealogy - but I'm happy to share what I've got with anyone who needs it!