Could you be referring to Melville M Chubbuck who was married to a Mary West, and they had a daughter Fanny or Fannie?
Melville M Chubbuck was the brother of my great grandmother Alice (Chubbuck) Wellington, and Alice resided in West Eaton, NY, having married Leroy Wellington.Her mother was Mary Ann Flemming (per Mary Ann's death cert).I have tried for years to find out who their Alice and Melville's father was. It was a ? Chubbuck.Do you have any idea who he might have been?
Alice was born in Silver Creek, in Chautauqua Co, and I have a feeling Melville may have been born there also about 1841.I get the impression that perhaps their father (Mary Ann's husband) may have passed away at a very young age there. Before 1850, Mary Ann was living in the Morrisville, NY area, and married a John Wales from Morrisville.
Do you know Fanny's husband's full name and when they married or where they or their son Carl may have lived?I have tried so long to find a possible descendent along the way that might have some info.
Melville and Mary had a son Wallace Chubbuck that I found living with them on I believe it was the 1880 census, but I lose track of Wallace there.Do you know if he grew to maturity and married, and possibly might have descendents?
Any info you have would be appreciated.I would like to see any pictures you may have of them also.It is my understanding Melville died in CA about 1904, possibly earlier, in Santa Cruz, CA. I am not immediately locating the info I had on the three of them, but did not want to hold up my reply to you.