Re: Thomas Climie/Mary Jane Hull

I have a difficult time believing the Thomas CLIMIE who married Harriet BECKWITH in 1839 was the same Thomas who married Mary Jane HULL because both sets of parents had a son named Andrew!

Thomas & Harriet's son Andrew born 1840 in Plympton Twp married 3 times and died in 1919.

It's hard to believe that he and Harriet would have named their 1st born Andrew after his father IF he and Mary Jane had already named their son Andrew and both of these Andrews appear to have lived?