Susan, My great grandmother Eliza (Cluggish) Butler had living with her Fannie Cluggish born abt 1802 Scotland. My g-granmother was a widow lady with young son. This Fannie is about 33 years older than my g-grandmother. A possible sister to my gg-grandfather William Richard Cluggish born Scotland. The census in 1860 for Henry County Indiana Maybe we will connect the Cluggish and Cluggage!! Tell me about your Fannie. There is a Fannie in Eliza's brother's line. These siblings were all born in the 1830's time frame. Please email me.