In checking my Cluggage info I find a number of Jane's. I show: Robert Cluggage who died around 1763-1770. wf. Janet(Jane) Children: Robert - unmarried James- wf. Ann and 6 children (had a Jane who m. James Cluggage) George - unmarried Gaven - wf. Mgt Davis5 children (had a Jane m. Mathew Gilliland) Francis - wf. Jane10 children (had a Jane who m. James Hannah) Thomas - wf.1 child (had a Jean(Jane)m. Daniel Montague Do you have any date for the marriage? I would think that one of these Jane's husband died young and she remarried. Francis who died in 1804 would be my guess.