Marge, thank you so much for taking the time to look into my Counterman family. The Rich family that I am researching were Quakers who migrated from PA > NC > IN > KS. This evening I found, in the "Encyclopedia of Quaker Genealogy", a family containing a James & William H. Counterman that lived (1887) in Delaware Co., Ohio. They were members of the Alum Creek Monthly Meeting which had connections with Monthly Meetings in Indiana. These Counterman's were there during the same time span as my Rich's so there may be a possible connection. Unfortunatly there is not enough useful information to make a connection.
Something strange - the 1910 census lists Rachel as a widow and the 1920 census lists her as being divorced.- go figure!
I will keep you in mind should I find anything concrete.