I know that I have been in contact with you before on this Crooks-McGahey line, but this seems too close to not explore more.I do have a Mary McGaughey b. 1797-1804 who married Benjamin Crooks, b. 1793 in Ireland. Benjamin was the son of James and Jane Crooks and a younger brother to Samuel Crooks of Middlesex twnshp., Butler Co., PA.Benjamin and Mary moved to Madison twnshp., Richmond Co., Ohio along with Benjamin's mother Jane Crooks.Children's names of Benjamin and Mary were:James, Martha, Margaret, Lily, Mary, and Alexander.Birthdates range from abt. 1825-1837.
I'm thinking that the names McGahey and McGaughey are one and the same!How does this work for you?