I made the previous comment too hurriedly.Charlotte's birthdate was incorrect; she was born 31 Dec 1814. I have more from Calvin's obituary. "The earlier part of his life was spent in (Vermont).In 1832 he came to Ohio and commenced to work on a stage line which then ran from Ashtabula to onneat(?) and from Cleveland to Ashtabula.He was married to Charlotte Dake October 5, 1834 (in Bloomfield, Trumbull, OH). They resided in Bloomfield and he worked in a distillery with his wife's father."In checking censuses, I found no Dakes in Trumbull County in any census, but I did find a J. Dake in 1830 in Ashtabula, Ashtabula, OH and a Jacob Dake in Sug....Twp in Wayne County, OH in 1840.Could Jacob be Charlotte's father or brother? Calvin and Charlotte had only three children: James, Jane and William J.Does this match anyone's family?