As noted earlier, 'my' Rueben Dieter and Catherine Markham were from Northampton PA and then Canaseraga,Burns twp, Allegany Co, NY. I have no record of a Consuela in their 17 children. There were several other Rueben Dieters from PA in the 17-1800's and you may be related to one of them. Good luck in your research - it is satisfying and fun, particularly when you make a good solid connection. Don't give up.