Hi, I'm wondering where you came by the info that four brothers came to the U.S. I trace back to Elias Tingler (b. 1810?) and I can't connect to the next generation back from him, but there is speculation his father was Michael Tingler who was in West Virginia in the 1790's.
Could this be the missing fourth brother?
Do you know what the brothers were trying to do or how they got here? Who there father was? Where they came from?