Couldn't resist adding a couple tidbits to your message.
The first husband of Wealthy Ann (Rideout) TROTT who married second, Phineas Judson MALLETT) was Samuel D. TROTT, b. 1855, died E. Winn 1887.He was brother to Amos and therefore Charles M. TROTT's uncle.Samuel D was the youngest of a large string of uncles, and Charles M was the oldest nephew.Therefore they were only a few years apart and ended up marrying sisters.Thanks for filling us in!
One disagreement, which you may have better data on. Charles M.'s middle name is usually given as McAlpine.You show Milton.Did that come from a record you have seen?