Brenda, With these additional dates, I can see the problem. I identified William Wilhite as married to Martha Jane Dossett (1850-?) and her parents were Thomas Dossett, jr. and Sarah Shank. Your Martha Jane Dossett (1854-1870) parents were Henry Dossett (a brother to Martha Jane Dossett (1850-?) and Nancy Ann Hayden. I concur now that your Martha Jane Dossett had a sister named Joanna Dossett (1858-?). Thank you for the correction and additional information. However, I still lack additional information for you on the Wilhite family line. Loveless ... Have a William Loveless (?-?) married to a Catherine Reneer (b. 1861 in Huntsville, Kentucky Butler County) and (d. 1880-1881). Her parents were Richard Reneer and Sara Taylor. Rumble ... Have a Adam Rumble (1804-?) married to a Frances Dossett (?-?) and she was the daughter of Thomas Dossett and Nancy Cates.