Hello Brad: Have a question as I review this information and compare it to the probate record for Duling, William Sr.
Probate lists nine children:William Collin, Edmond, Sarah Ann Dean, Achilles, Elijah, Nancy Knabenshue (hus., Jacob), Ruth Dean, Eliza James (dec'd, her children) and Zecheriah.
You list three children that are slightly different:William Alexander vs William Collin, Sarah Ann Duling vs Sarah Ann Dean (is this the same person with married name?), Eliza James vs Elizabeth (is this the same person with married name?)
You don't list Achilles, Elijah, Nancy Knabenshue, or Ruth Dean.
Only Edmond and Zecheriah seem to be the same on both lists.
And you list a Colin Campbell Duling where Collin is part of William in the probate record.
You have obviously been doing research on this family for some time but I'm not sure what to do with this discrepency.Help!