I hope you get this, it's been awhile since you last posted. I'm not sure about your family.......actually, I'm not real sure about my husbands family either. I do know that your family and his family are from the same area. I ran across something about Nancy Alvira Dunklee (this is how it was spelled when I found her). She and her husband where on a census for I believe Horicon, NY, not sure of the date. Nancy parents lived in NH they moved to the Horicon-Ticonderoga, NY area and had Nancy. She then married Royal Bennett in 1848. My husbands family is from Hague, NY, they say they have always lived there, however, I can't find a Dunklee in this area before 1882. His family is the Dayton, Elmer, Jordan, Bevely, Howard and David Dunklee all from Hague, NY. Dayton is the father and the rest are his children not including his daugther Mary. The names you had listed where not familiar to me however Nancy is the earliest Dunklee I can find in the area. Maybe there is a relation, not sure yet. If you know anything please let me know.