I have an ANN DUTCHER PLUMMER born 9-9-1814 in Sheffield, NB, Canada. She married Charles Wellington Tilley. I have no idea where the Dutcher comes from. Ann's parents were John Plummer and Sarah Stewart. I tend to wonder is maybe Sarah's maiden name was Dutcher not Stewart or that Sarah might have been married to a Stewart before marrying John Plummer. I also have this in my notes from the Sheffield United Church Cemtery: Sarah Dutcher w/o Jas Dutcher d...sunken stone. Then Jane Dutcher d. 11 March 1853 ae22 years. Hope this helps a bit!