Hi Paul -Hopefully this will help you out a little bit.I am attempting to prove or disprove that this Matthew P. Dutcher connects to the family of John & Martha (Thomas) Dutcher family who also resided in Orleans Co., NY.
DAR Records Orleans Chapter, DAR [Albion, Orleans Co., NY] Dutcher Family Record; H. & E. Phinneys Stereotype Edition The Holy Bible Cooperstown, N.Y.; Stereotyped, Printed and Published by H. & E. Phinney, 1830:
Marriages: Matthew P. Dutcher was married to Sarah Ann Prindle September 18, 1821 Daniel P. Dutcher was married to Samantha Greenman October 16, 1844 James Hays Jr. was married to Jemima Dutcher February 24, 1848 Caroline Dutcher was married to Daniel B. Allen April 16, 1855 Ann Eliza Dutcher was married to Elisha Townsend March 4, 1858 Hannah Dutcher was married to Henry Miller July 12, 1864 Sarah J. Dutcher was married to A. Allen October 17, 1849
Births: Mathew P. Dutcher was borned June 12, 1799 Sarah Ann Dutcher was borned September 30, 1805 Daniel P. Dutcher was borned July 12, 1822 David Smith Dutcher was borned April 25, 1824. Died September 18, 1824 Sarah Jane Dutcher was borned February 15, 1825 Jemima Dutcher was borned August 16, 1828 Louisa Dutcher was borned April 25, 1831 Ann Eliza Dutcher was borned October 25, 1833 Caroline Dutcher was borned December 5, 1835 Catherine Matilda Dutcher was borned January 31, 1837 Mary Dutcher was borned December 12, 1839 Hannah P. Dutcher was borned ______ 16, 1842 Mary Frances Dutcher was borned 30th of June 1844 Emma Eugenia Dutcher was born September 6, 1846
The page on which deaths were recorded was torn so no names can be read.