Hello debby, (or perhaps someone else on same track), I sent you an e-mail confirming that, almost beyond doubt, we have details of the same William Duthie and his 9 siblings.He was my gggrandfather,brother to James and John(Jack) who went to the USA 1880ish ending up in Detroit. Other details you give match up e.g. Mary married a Mr.Stewart(it was their daughter Gertrude who supplied the info I've got). Maggie married an Austrian Count called Schmidt. Hoping to hear from you (or anyone else searching same family) Katreena.