This is what I have in my data base:John Duty b. 23 Dec 1799 in NC; d. 22 Oct. 1867 in Franklin County, IL; m. Anna M. Grant on 13 Apr 1824 in Posey County, IN. She was b. 10 May 1805 in VA; d. 14 Apr 1868 in Franklin County, IL.John and Anna Grant are buried at Old Drummond Cemetery in Franklin County, IL. They had 13 children: 1. William Washington Duty b. 23 May 1825 in Posey County, IN; d. 24 Feb 1897 in Whittington, Franklin County, IL; married 1st on 25 May 1850: Sarah Winemiller b. abt 1827 in Posey County, IN.; d. 1854 in Franklin County, IL. Sarah is the dtr of James Winemiller and Frances (Shivers) Winemiller. Married 2nd on 16 Aug 1855 in Franklin County, IL: Nancy Winemiller b. 1834 in Posey County, IN; d. aft. 1900 in Franklin County, IL.; Nancy is the dtr of James Winemiller and Frances (Shivers)Winemiller. 2. Moses Duty b. 28 Jun 1826 3. John Duty b. 06 Oct 1827 4. Daniel Duty b. 11 Jan 1829 5. Maranda Duty b. 04 Dec 1831 6. James Alexander Duty b. 22 Nov 1833 7. Thomas Edward Duty b. 07 Oct 1835 8. Moneca Duty b. 22 May 1838 9. Elizabeth Duty b. 25 Jun 1840 10.Martha Duty b. 05 Mar 1842 11.Elijah Duty b. 22 Oct. 1844 in Posey County, IN. (No additional info for him, but have been told he was married to Elizabeth Reeder on 20 Mar 1862 in Posey County, IN.). 12.Anna Duty b. 1846 13.Hiram Duty b. 28 Oct 1849 Could the above child, Elijah Duty be the one you are questioning?If so, what source do you have that Elijah Duty married Nancy Winemiller?