I still haven't figured out where my William and Elizabeth Duty fits in the Duty puzzle for the Indiana/Illinois family. I know my William is not the William Jr. but it is someone in the family. My Elizabeth Duty was married in 1848 to John N Hawkins. She was born in Posey County and lived in Vanderburgh County after marriage. In some of the later census records, her father, William Duty is living with John N Hawkins and herself. The census records indicate he was born around 1802 and Elizabeth Duty was born between 1824 and 1826. It cannot be the William Duty born in 1797 because his daughter was born in 1840...does anyone have a clue?By the way, I am assuming both John N Hawkins and Elizabeth Duty died before 1880 as I cannot find them on census anywhere and my gggrandfather, at the age of 14, was living elsewhere. His siblings also died in childhood. Shortly thereafter, my gggrandfather, Oscar relocated to Illinois where other Duty's were located.