I live in Ireland and we are just back from 3 weeks in the states, hence my late reply.
The southern New York location partly answers my question on how the Eggleton name seems to have died away in Wayne Co. and where those ancestors may be now.
I am particularly interested in the father of Clarence and Leslie who was John and supposedly born in England. I have had trouble finding him after 1900, maybe that's when the family moved? but I would be most interested in any information you have.
I will email your forum address direct later this week when I have had a chance to check my notes again.