Valentine and Sophia's son Daniel is my great-great-great Grandpa, his son David is what line I'm from. This definitely fits. I do know that Daniel had a son who was married to Linda Booram (or Boram) and also a grandson named Daniel who was married to Isabelle Catherine Ross. I don't know if either of them moved to Indiana of not.
Hope this helps you a little bit,too.
Thanks for your help, thought I was at a dead end on Sophia.