My ancestor was James Fogarty. The dates sound accurate, but couldn't confirm as my computer crashed yesterday afternoon. Once I get it back up, I'll take a look to see if it's him. I know "James" was a very popular name and there were numerous "James Fogarty's". It is possible that my "James" could have been a child of one of the Fogarty's you mentioned since he was born in Tipperary.