I don't have much information on the Fullington side of the family, but according to Ida A. Fullington Makely's Death Certificate, she was born in Schoharie County, New York.Most of the Makely's at that time were from Manorkill and Ravena, New York.
Ida's parents were Ephram Fullington and Catherine E. Watson according to her Death Certificate.Ida Fullington Makely died on 13 Mar 1937 and was born 17 Jun 1860.Her husband was Addison Makely.
Ida was buried in Chestnut Lawn Cemetery in Ravena, New York.You might want to check with them and see if they have any more Fullington's buried there.If they are located there, then you can get a copy of the death certificate.
Considering that PHILIP FULLINGTON was born in 1840, he MIGHT be a brother to EPHRAM FULLINGTON.I don't have a birthdate on Ephram, but I would assume that he was probably born around that time frame.
If you look down the list, look for and try sending an e-mail to Dan Makely.He has done extensive work on the Makely family and he might have information on the Fullington's since Ida was married to Addison Makely.
Sorry I can't help you with Philip; but if you are looking for Fullington's in the Schoharie County area, chances are you are in the right tree.In summation I'd check with Dan Makely, Schoharie/Columbia County area of NY and Chestnut Lawn Cemetery, Ravena, NY.