Fredric; I am not familiar with who the editor is of the 4th book. Have you forwarded the 4 pages from the second edition of Adventurers of Purse & Person regarding the Gaither family to them to ask their opinion? D.A.R. and Society of Ancient Planters and probably most other societies , accept the work published in Adventurers of Purse & Person. I am not related so have no reply to you as to verosity other than the reputation of these books. Ginny K.