You have information that I do not have. I have Robert as being married twice. Once to Mary A W Johnson on October 31,1849. This was both of their 2nd marriages. Her full name was Mary Ann "unknown Maiden" who married a man with the last name Welsh. He died and Robert's first wife named Jane Henderson? died. They married late in life. I am unsure of much else about that. I have everything from Marion Mitchell on down including portraits and addresses of the family cemetaries. There are 3 for the Pattersons. My grandmother is 94 and still lives one block away from the old homestead where Marion was born. Our house was hit by the tornado last September and I haven't done much on this line. I was busy working on the other side. I live in Beech Grove and my email should be available if you want to chat. efrancis19 at comcast dot net. I will have to go back through paperwork and verify that the information I have is correct on Robert and his wives. I am no expert and wasn't there back then,, so you could be right. I do know that I need to take a week off and go to the cemetaries in Indianapolis and research them for our people. I have censuswork. I am imagining that Annie would be buried in the Patterson Cemetary, which is close to Bargersville. I haven't been there since I was a teenager, but I really am needing to go anyway. I can go and see what I come up with.