I saw your post and would like you to know that Elnathan was my great-great-geat grandfather. One of his sons was Alonzo born about 1836.His son was Ernest who was born in 1863. My grandfather was Glenn W. Gazley and my dad was Donald M. Gazley who passed away in 2003.
I have seen Elnathan's grave in Pine Plains, New York.
I would really like the chance to talk with you at some point.