I have been searching for David also. I am related through Andrew. Frederick Gibbens was born in Harrison Co, OH and marriedAnn Ferrier, also born in Harrison Co, OH. Frederick and Ann/Anna moved back to Williams Co, OH, after 1850. His son, William, was born in 1850 in York Township, Steuben Co, IN. The ones before were born in Williams Co, OH although I have seen a census that said Andrew was born in MI. It is just across the state line from Williams Co. There was more children after William.
In one census it says there is a son named Alonzo. I couldn't find him after that until I found out that his name was James Alonzo. He went by Jay. He is living in MI when he was married. Olive was the baby. I have listed my information with dates on Rootsweb.