I have a John Francis Gilstrap that is the son of James Lewis & Anna Baldwin Gilstrap. Could be the John your are looking for as John Francis was married three times. 1st to Anna Baldwin, 2nd to Martha McCary and 3rd to Martha Vaughn.. The only glitch to this being the correct John F is that I have one marriage for him an that is to a Iva Watkins. He could have been married earlier but their first child, Homer Leroy was born in 1905, I do not have any record of a Sarah Ann Holt... I do have some other connection between the Gilstrap's and the Holt's but those transpired back in the middle 1700's in NC.