Hi Cousin, Roby we are kin and my line runs thru Samuel Godkin and Julia Kannengeisser. Orly was in the civil war, I think that he was in the calvary, but then that is not for sure. He fought for the north while a cousin fought for the South. Some of your facts are wrong though. Julia Anna Kannengeisser was married to Samuel Edward Godkin b. 25 Feb. 1845. M. 27 sep. 1869. Julia's birth is correct. I would really like to talk with you and get a copy of that photo. We have family reunions every year here in Texas near Houston usually in the spring. We just had one for this year. Family comes from all over, Canada, Florida, Oregon and Minnesota. We haven't got any of the family from New York to come yet, but I am working on getting them here. At the age of 60, I am not getting any younger. I will email you to see that you find this message.